15% off all orders placed, use discount code BF15 ends 30th November

Free UK standard delivery on all orders *UK mainland only

Digital Planner Apps vs Paper Desk Pads for ADHD: An Honest Comparison

Digital Planner Apps vs Paper Desk Pads for ADHD: An Honest Comparison

The short answer: Neither a planner app nor a paper desk pad is "best for ADHD". Apps such as Tiimo and Thruday win on reminders, timers and flexibility, but they live on the device most likely to distract you. Paper wins on visibility, zero notifications and better recall in at least one brain-imaging study, but it can't buzz you when it's time to leave. Many people with ADHD get the best results from a hybrid: paper for the plan you look at all day, phone alarms for the moments you can't miss.

Why your planner choice matters more with ADHD

If you've ever downloaded a shiny new planner app on Sunday night and forgotten it existed by Wednesday, you're in good company. The NHS lists "being easily distracted or forgetful", "finding it hard to organise your time" and "losing things often" among the common signs of ADHD in adults.

Underneath that sits working memory, the mental notepad we use to hold a plan in mind. A 2013 meta-analysis of 38 studies in Neuropsychology found adults with ADHD showed moderate working-memory differences compared with adults without ADHD. That's why a planner isn't a nice-to-have. It's an external brain, and it only works if you actually look at it.

So the real question isn't "digital or paper?" It's "which one will I still be using in a month, and which one pulls me off-task the least?" Let's look at the evidence.

Meet the contenders

We've picked two well-known ADHD-focused apps and the two paper formats people ask us about most.

  • Tiimo is a visual daily planner built with ADHD and autism in mind. It has colour-coded timelines, a visual focus timer, AI task breakdown and Apple Watch support. It was named Apple's iPhone App of the Year 2025, and the company says over half a million people use it.
  • Thruday is a visual daily planner from UK founder Andy Cresswell, built from lived experience of ADHD, autism and epilepsy. It combines a timeline, routines, focus timers, mood tracking and a journal, and lets a partner or carer help plan for free. It reports 40,000+ users.
  • An A3 desk pad is a large tear-off daily planner that sits flat on your desk. You can see the whole day at a glance without picking anything up.
  • An A5 planner is a portable bound planner for your bag. It's useful for students moving between lectures, or anyone whose day isn't spent at one desk.

Price: free to start, but subscriptions add up

Both apps have a free tier, so on day one digital is cheaper. The difference shows up over a year, and in what the free version leaves out.

Option Free version Paid price (UK) Cost over 12 months
Thruday Visual planning and to-do lists £7/month or £35/year £35 (annual) to £84 (monthly)
Tiimo Selection of planning tools on iOS and Android only Pro in-app purchases listed from £6.49 to £39.99; US price $7.99/month or $79.99/year (Lifestack, July 2026) Up to about £40 (annual)
A3 desk pad — £14 for a 50-page pad, or 3 for £25 About £45 (5 pads at multi-buy prices, one page per working day)
A5 planner — £11 for 90 days, or 3 for £26 About £37 (4 planners at multi-buy prices)

Prices as listed on the UK App Store in November 2026. Tiimo says prices vary by location and are confirmed at checkout, and its web planner needs a paid plan or trial.

Over a full year, the costs are closer than you might expect: roughly £35–45 for a paid app or a year's supply of paper. Paper has no free tier, but there's also no subscription to remember to cancel, no feature behind a paywall and no card details stored. The honest hidden cost of paper is replacement: a daily tear-off pad runs out, and a lost A5 planner can't be restored from the cloud.

Ease of use: quick to start vs easy to keep going

Paper has the lowest barrier to entry: pick up a pen and write. In a University of Tokyo study of 48 adults aged 18–29, people noted down a two-month schedule in about 11 minutes on paper, compared with 14 minutes on a tablet and 16 minutes on a smartphone. That's roughly 25% faster on paper.

Apps ask more of you up front: downloads, accounts, settings and notification permissions. In return, they do more of the heavy lifting afterwards. Recurring routines appear automatically, tasks can be dragged to tomorrow, and Tiimo can break a vague task into smaller steps with time estimates. Users seem to like them: Tiimo rates 4.5/5 from 4,200 UK App Store ratings and Thruday 4.4/5 from 87.

The tricky part for both is sticking with it. There's no published retention data for planner apps specifically. However, a 2019 study of 93 popular mental-health apps found that a median of only 3.9% of users were still opening them after 15 days. Paper has its own version of this problem: a planner shut in a drawer is as forgotten as an app buried on page three. Whichever you pick, put it where you can't avoid seeing it.

Distractions: the elephant in the app

This is where the honest answer gets interesting, because the research doesn't all point one way.

What's clear is that notifications cost attention. In a Florida State University experiment published in the Journal of Experimental Psychology, people who received a phone notification during a focus task were more than three times as likely to make errors. That held even when they didn't pick the phone up.

What's less clear is whether a silent phone on your desk harms you. A widely shared 2017 "Brain Drain" study of nearly 800 people found that those whose phones were in another room did better on concentration tests than those with phones on the desk. But a 2024 meta-analysis pooling 33 studies and 4,368 participants found no significant effect from a phone's mere presence. So we won't tell you your phone is draining your brain just by sitting there.

There's also the time question. UK adults now spend an average of 4 hours 30 minutes online a day outside work, mostly on smartphones, according to Ofcom. That rises to 6 hours 20 minutes for 18–24 year olds. For teenagers, a JAMA study of 2,587 students linked frequent digital media use with later ADHD symptoms (about 10% vs 5%), though the authors stress it doesn't prove cause.

What this means in practice: the planner app itself isn't the distraction. The problem is that checking your plan means unlocking the same device that holds your messages, socials and email. A desk pad has no notifications, no feed and no "just one quick look". To be fair to the apps, both Tiimo and Thruday are ad-free and include focus timers designed to keep you on task.

Memory: does writing it down help you remember?

There's some evidence it does, with sensible caveats.

In the same University of Tokyo study, people who used a paper datebook answered simple recall questions more accurately an hour later. fMRI scans also showed more activity in memory-related areas, including the hippocampus. The researchers think paper's physical cues help: where something sits on the page, crossings-out and your own handwriting. Their take-home message was to "use paper notebooks for information we need to learn or memorize".

A separate 2024 EEG study of 36 university students found handwriting created much more widespread brain connectivity than typing. Interestingly, participants wrote with a digital pen on a touchscreen, so this is a point for handwriting rather than for paper itself.

The caveats: both studies were small, neither involved participants with ADHD, and the EEG study measured brain activity rather than real-world results. Neither proves paper will make you more organised. But if you often forget what you planned, writing it by hand is a low-cost thing to try.

Digital planner apps: pros and cons

Pros

  • Reminders that find you. Alarms and notifications are the one thing paper can't do, and they're invaluable for time blindness.
  • Visual timers. Tiimo and Thruday both have focus timers that make time visible.
  • Flexible plans. Dragging a task to tomorrow is easier than rewriting it, so there's less "I've ruined the page" guilt.
  • Help getting started. Tiimo's AI breaks a task into steps, which can help with task paralysis.
  • Always with you. Plans sync across phone, watch and web.
  • Support from others. Thruday lets a partner or carer help plan for free.
  • Low cost to try. Both have free tiers.

Cons

  • Your planner lives next to your distractions. Checking a task means unlocking the device that has everything else on it.
  • Notification fatigue. Notifications are proven to cost attention, and too many reminders get ignored.
  • Out of sight. A closed app shows you nothing until you choose to open it.
  • Ongoing cost. Premium features cost about £35–40 a year, every year.
  • Battery and screen dependence. No charge means no plan.
  • Data sharing. Both apps collect account data such as your name and email (per their App Store privacy labels). Tiimo also lists identifiers used for tracking.

Paper desk pads and planners: pros and cons

Pros

  • Always visible. An A3 desk pad sits in your eyeline all day, without you having to remember to check it.
  • No notifications, no feed. Nothing on the page will tempt you towards social media.
  • Faster to write. Paper was about 25% quicker in the Tokyo study.
  • May help memory. There's early evidence that handwriting and paper's physical cues support recall.
  • Satisfying to finish. Ticking a box or tearing off a finished day gives you a small hit of progress.
  • Simple to use. No set-up, updates, logins or battery.
  • Private. Your plans aren't stored on anyone's server.

Cons

  • It can't remind you. A desk pad won't tell you it's 2:45 and you need to leave.
  • Only where you left it. An A3 pad stays on the desk, and an A5 planner only helps if it's in your bag.
  • Rewriting is a pain. Moving tasks means copying them out again, which can feel discouraging on a bad day.
  • No back-up. Lose it and it's gone.
  • Repeat purchases. Pads run out and need replacing.
  • Blank-page guilt. Missed days are visible, which some people find motivating and others find off-putting.

Side-by-side comparison

Tiimo Thruday A3 desk pad A5 planner
Free option Yes (iOS/Android) Yes No No
Paid price (UK) Up to about £40/year £7/month or £35/year £14 per 50-page pad £11 per 90-day planner
Reminders and alarms Yes Yes No No
Visual timer Yes Yes No No
Always visible Widgets only No Yes When open
Notifications nearby Yes Yes None None
Portable Yes Yes No Yes
Works without a charged device No No Yes Yes
Easy to reschedule Yes Yes Rewrite Rewrite
Backed up if lost Yes Yes No No
Best for Visual timelines, routines, time blindness Routines, mood tracking, shared planning Desk-based days, at-a-glance focus Students, people on the move

So which should you choose?

Be honest about what tends to trip you up. That's a better guide than which option looks nicest.

  • If you lose track of time or miss appointments, you need something that can interrupt you. That means an app or, at the very least, phone alarms.
  • If you open your phone to check your plan and end up scrolling 20 minutes later, keep your plan on paper and your phone face down in a drawer.
  • If you work or study at one desk, an A3 desk pad keeps the whole day in view without you having to remember to look.
  • If you're moving between lectures, shifts or sites, an A5 planner or an app travels with you.
  • If rigid systems make you give up, start small: a three-item daily list on paper, or the free tier of an app, before you commit money to either.

The hybrid approach

Many people with ADHD don't choose one. A common set-up looks like this:

  1. Plan on paper. Spend five minutes each morning writing the day on your desk pad. Writing it by hand is quick and gives you a better chance of remembering it.
  2. Set only the reminders you truly need. Use your phone or an app just for the moments you can't miss: leaving for the train, a medication dose or a meeting.
  3. Keep the pad in view and the phone out of reach. Notifications are the proven distraction, so turn off everything that isn't a reminder.
  4. Reset weekly. Carry unfinished tasks forward without guilt. Moving a task isn't a failure; it's planning.

Paper plus a visual timer: the phone-free middle ground

The biggest thing apps have over paper is the timer. That matters, because time blindness is more than a meme. A 2021 meta-analysis of 55 studies in the Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry found consistent small-to-medium differences in time perception in people with ADHD. These showed up when people judged, estimated and reproduced lengths of time.

A standalone visual timer gives a paper planner that missing piece without bringing your phone back to the desk. You write the task on your pad, set the timer for that task, and watch the time count down, with no notifications to tempt you. A few things to look for:

  • One-step start. Flip-to-start or a physical dial means less friction than unlocking a phone.
  • Remaining time you can see at a glance, such as a filling display or large numbers, rather than a small digital readout.
  • A silent mode, for libraries, shared offices or anyone who finds a beeping alarm stressful.

To be clear about the evidence: the research shows the time-perception difficulty is real. We couldn't find any trials testing whether visual timers improve outcomes for adults with ADHD, so treat a timer as a sensible, low-cost experiment, not a proven fix. We make two, the Cube gravity timer (£16: flip to start, with a beep at adjustable volume) and the Hour Glass visual timer (£19), but any visual timer that suits you will do the job.

The best planner is the one you'll still be using next month. Give yourself permission to experiment, and to switch if something stops working.

Frequently asked questions

Is a paper planner or an app better for ADHD?

Neither is better for everyone. Apps are better at reminders and timers, while paper is better at staying visible and free of notifications. Research shows notifications measurably hurt focus, and a small study found paper planning was faster and easier to recall. Many adults with ADHD combine both.

How much do ADHD planner apps cost in the UK?

Both Tiimo and Thruday have free versions. Thruday Premium costs £7 a month or £35 a year on the UK App Store. Tiimo Pro in-app purchases are listed between £6.49 and £39.99, and the exact price depends on your plan and region.

Does writing things down by hand help with ADHD?

No study has tested this in people with ADHD specifically. In general populations, a University of Tokyo study found people who planned on paper recalled simple details better and showed more activity in memory-related brain areas. A 2024 EEG study found handwriting engaged wider brain networks than typing.

Is having my phone on the desk bad for concentration?

Notifications clearly are: one study found people were more than three times as likely to make errors on an attention task. The evidence on a silent phone simply being nearby is mixed. A 2024 meta-analysis of 33 studies found no significant effect.

What size planner is best for ADHD?

It depends on where you plan. An A3 desk pad suits a fixed desk because it's big enough to stay in your eyeline all day. An A5 planner suits students and anyone on the move because it fits in a bag.

A note from us

We're Glitch and Glow, a neurodiversity productivity company, and we make A3 daily desk pads and A5 planners for adults and students. We obviously love paper, but we've tried to give apps a fair hearing here, because the right tool is the one that works for your brain. See the ADHD Day Planner Desk Pad (A3) and The Curiosity Planner (A5).

References

  1. Alderson, R. M. et al. (2013). ADHD and working memory in adults: a meta-analytic review. Neuropsychology, 27(3), 287–302.
  2. Baumel, A., Muench, F., Edan, S. & Kane, J. M. (2019). Objective user engagement with mental health apps. Journal of Medical Internet Research, 21(9), e14567.
  3. Hartanto, A. et al. (2024). The effect of mere presence of smartphone on cognitive functions: a four-level meta-analysis. Technology, Mind, and Behavior, 5(1).
  4. Marx, I., Cortese, S., Koelch, M. G. & Hacker, T. (2021). Meta-analysis: altered perceptual timing abilities in ADHD. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry. Summary via ADHD Evidence.
  5. NHS. ADHD in adults.
  6. Ofcom (2025). Online Nation 2025, as reported by ISPreview.
  7. Ra, C. K. et al. (2018). Association of digital media use with subsequent symptoms of ADHD among adolescents. JAMA, 320(3), 255–263.
  8. Stothart, C., Mitchum, A. & Yehnert, C. (2015). The attentional cost of receiving a cell phone notification. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance. Summary via Medical Xpress.
  9. Umejima, K. et al. (2021). Paper notebooks vs. mobile devices: brain activation differences during memory retrieval. Frontiers in Behavioral Neuroscience. University of Tokyo press release.
  10. Van der Weel, F. R. & Van der Meer, A. L. H. (2024). Handwriting but not typewriting leads to widespread brain connectivity. Frontiers in Psychology.
  11. Ward, A. F., Duke, K., Gneezy, A. & Bos, M. W. (2017). Brain drain: the mere presence of one's own smartphone reduces available cognitive capacity. Journal of the Association for Consumer Research, 2(2). Summary via ScienceDaily.
  12. App pricing and ratings: Tiimo and Thruday on the UK App Store, accessed November 2026; Tiimo pricing page; Lifestack Tiimo pricing guide (July 2026).
  13. Product details: tiimoapp.com and thruday.com, accessed November 2026. Tiimo award: Daring Fireball.

 

Previous Perfect Desk Gifts for Someone with ADHD (That They'll Actually Use) Next The Pomodoro Technique for ADHD: Better Intervals Than 25/5

As seen in this post

Shop the post

The products featured in this article.

Your bag

Add £9.00 more to get £5 off